Keep Google Sheets if your studio reliably maintains one shared tracker. Try ClickUp Free when task discussions and shared views would solve a specific coordination gap; pay only for a missing capability. For five people, Asana is a paid option: its Personal plan allows two users.
Consider an illustrative US design studio: five nontechnical staff, eight concurrent client projects, 40 open tasks, existing Google Workspace and $0–60 a month for additional software, before tax. These are planning assumptions, not a client case. The goal is a maintained record of deliverables, owners, deadlines and waiting work, with a person checking completion.
This is a current-options decision, not a new product launch. Prices and plan limits below were checked on 18 November 2026; the comparison excludes existing Workspace fees, staff time, taxes, extra paid users and optional purchases.
What should your tracker make clear?
Before choosing an app, identify what is going wrong. Is there no agreed owner, an invisible blocker, a lost conversation, or a genuine need for more structured reporting? An app can provide somewhere to record a decision; buying it does not make the decision for the team.
For example, take a fictional brochure proof waiting for client copy. The useful record says who owns the proof, its agreed deadline, what is missing, who will chase it and who will review the result. Compare every option against that same job.
Ownership: can each person find the work they have agreed to do?
Visibility: can colleagues see waiting work, its next action and relevant discussion?
Access: can all five staff and any intended client reviewers see the right material?
Cost and upkeep: can the studio afford the whole-team commitment, maintain the records and obtain a usable copy when leaving?
What will five people actually pay?
All amounts are US dollars. Annual monthly equivalents spread a yearly price across 12 months; they are not monthly-cancellable bills. The table uses the displayed ClickUp rates and feature matrix and Asana rates and feature matrix. Confirm your checkout currency, seat count, tax, discounts and renewal terms before buying.
Option / best fit | Five-person cost | Commitment | Meaningful limits | Setup / access tradeoff |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Existing Sheets: a maintained shared tracker | $0 additional subscription under this scenario | No new subscription; existing Workspace bill remains | This proposed tracker relies on people to update and review it | Agree fields and saved views; a filtered view is not private client access |
$0 | Free tier, not a paid-plan trial | 60 MB storage; custom fields are trial-only; no view-only guests | Introduce task records and shared views; keep large source files separately | |
$45/month equivalent yearly, or $60 billed monthly | $540/year at the displayed yearly rate; all Workspace members must upgrade | Brain² model access is a trial; named view-export routes have restrictions | Adds guest permissions and unlimited storage; check access and exit needs before paying | |
$54.95/month equivalent yearly, or $67.45 billed monthly | $659.40/year; monthly billing exceeds this budget | Formal approvals and proofing require Advanced | Dependencies, custom fields and dashboards; staff must adopt the task workflow |
Asana Personal is excluded because its two-user allowance cannot accommodate this five-person team. Starter’s advertised unlimited free guests do not make employees free: Asana’s subscriber terms prohibit using guest access to avoid employee seats or sharing seats.
The annual calculations are 5 × $9 × 12 = $540 for ClickUp Core, and 5 × $10.99 × 12 = $659.40 for Asana Starter. Divide by 12 to get $45 and $54.95. On monthly billing, 5 × $12 = $60 for Core, while 5 × $13.49 = $67.45 for Starter—$7.45 over the ceiling.
That creates two budget tests: the monthly equivalent and cash available at purchase. Core monthly uses the full pre-tax allowance; Starter fits only on the annual equivalent. ClickUp’s yearly display also shows a crossed-out $12 regular-price label. Neither that label nor these calculations establishes how long the displayed offer lasts or what renewal will cost.
Reprice before hiring a sixth person. Asana lists single-seat increments from two to five users, then five-seat increments up to 30; do not assume you can simply add one seat at the same unit rate. ClickUp requires upgrading every Workspace member, not just the administrator.
When is your existing Sheets tracker enough?
Keep it when people can find their responsibilities, update progress and resolve blockers without maintaining another system. Start with a proposed seven-column record: project identifier, deliverable, accountable owner, agreed due date, status, blocker and next action, and source-file link.
For the brochure example, “Waiting” is not enough on its own. Add “Client copy needed; account lead to follow up” and retain the agreed delivery date. Useful status choices are Planned, In progress, Waiting, Ready for review and Done. These are team conventions, not an enforced approval system.
With edit access, select the tracker range and use Format > Convert to table. Google’s table documentation describes date, dropdown, people-chip and file-chip column types. Use these to make entries consistent; type warnings do not verify that an owner accepted a deadline.
Create saved views for each owner and for waiting work. Sheets filter views let colleagues inspect different subsets at the same time without changing everyone’s view. Saved views require edit access; viewers can use temporary views. None of these views changes who can access the underlying sheet.
Assign someone to check upcoming deadlines and waiting work each workday, and agree who can mark a reviewed deliverable Done. This is a suggested routine, not a proven optimum. If the missing step is an agreed review habit, establish that before changing tools.
Do not rely on a TODAY formula to email deadline reminders. Google says conditional notifications work only for certain work or school accounts, respond to cell changes and may be delayed or combined. Recalculation while the sheet is closed can miss the trigger. Existing Workspace access alone does not establish eligibility; keep the human-owned date check.
When would ClickUp or Asana justify the move?
ClickUp Free is worth considering when a row no longer provides enough context for the task discussion. Its pricing matrix includes list, board and calendar views, while its task documentation describes comments, subtasks and multiple assignees. The free tier’s unlimited members and tasks do not remove its storage and trial limits.
Core becomes a more specific purchase when the team needs ongoing custom fields or controlled guest permissions. Free custom fields are trial-only; Core includes them and lists unlimited storage. Keeping large design originals in Drive and linking them may make the basic tracker sufficient, but the team must maintain those file permissions. An ordinary file link is not the same as a native storage integration.
Asana Starter is a candidate when its dependencies and dashboards answer a real coordination or reporting need and the annual bill is affordable. Asana tasks have one assignee and can have many collaborators. ClickUp allows multiple assignees; naming one accountable owner remains a recommended team convention, not a restriction common to both products.
Do not buy Starter expecting formal proof approval. Its pricing matrix places approvals and proofing in Advanced, whose $24.99 annual per-user monthly equivalent would be 5 × $24.99 = $124.95 for this team. A Ready for review status plus a named human reviewer is a manual alternative, not the same product feature.
Meeting capture is a separate purchase decision. The guide to Google Meet notes and reviewed client-call decisions covers that upstream step; only agreed actions should become project tasks.
Can clients see only their own work?
Treat client access as a buying criterion, not a finishing touch. Do not send a filtered internal sheet as though it were a private client portal. If clients need only a progress update, a separate, deliberately shared summary may be sufficient.
Check the tracker and its linked design files separately. Google Drive’s sharing guide explains viewer, commenter and editor roles, and that files inherit access from their parent folder. A file generally cannot grant less access than that parent; use an appropriately scoped location instead of assuming a different link fixes it.
ClickUp’s current matrix excludes view-only guests from Free and includes them in Core. Asana Starter lists private projects, comment-only projects and free guests. Those capabilities still need configuring. Before inviting a client, check the intended guest role, billable-user treatment and visibility; a task invitation does not by itself prove access to a linked Drive file.
Do you need the AI features?
No AI is required for the proposed owner, deadline and blocker record. If you enable it, start with a bounded internal draft—such as a task summary or suggested subtasks—and have someone check it before it changes a commitment.
As checked on 18 November, Asana Starter lists five monthly AI requests per user, capped at 50 per account. For five users that is 25 included requests, not 50. Its 50,000 monthly AI Studio credits are a separate allowance, not another expression of the same requests.
The ClickUp Core card labels Brain² a trial and lists 1,000 pooled credits per user per month: 5 × 1,000 = 5,000 credits for this team. That does not establish permanent unrestricted model access, a trial duration or a number of completed project tasks. Both vendors offer additional usage; the budget above includes no extra AI purchases. Check paid-usage and top-up settings before enabling them.
Keep a person responsible for assignments, changed dates, completion and client-facing updates. Asana’s AI terms require output checks and prohibit assigning work based on individual behavior or characteristics. ClickUp’s AI terms require checking output and make customers responsible for instructed actions, including actions outside ClickUp. Ordinary task tracking does not require behavior-based allocation.
For client material, review the applicable data terms before enabling AI. Asana says customer data is not used by it or its AI partners to train the generative models providing Asana AI; that is not a zero-retention promise. ClickUp restricts sensitive or regulated AI inputs without a separate agreement. Start with dummy material for the adoption check.
What are the renewal and exit conditions?
Treat an annual purchase as a commitment. Asana’s subscriber terms require at least 30 days’ notice for seat reductions, downgrades or nonrenewal, subject to the applicable order or controlling agreement. Its fees are generally noncancelable and nonrefundable. ClickUp’s terms require at least 30 days’ notice before annual renewal for cancellation or downgrades, including reducing users or removing add-ons.
Do not assume ClickUp’s refund headline makes every annual purchase a risk-free trial. Its guarantee has exclusions, including renewals, expansions and certain sales-assisted or post-trial purchases. Check the applicable order and put the notice deadline in a calendar.
Check how to leave before moving all the work. Google documents file downloads and Asana lists CSV/PDF export across plans. Neither establishes that a chosen export preserves every comment, attachment, permission or relationship.
ClickUp’s pricing matrix excludes List View exports from Free, labels them a trial on Core, and puts Table View exports on Business or above. These are restrictions on named export routes, not proof that every other account-level export is unavailable. Full-workspace export behavior and fidelity remain unverified here; confirm a usable exit route before adopting.
What should you try before moving all eight projects?
Use a small dummy project first. The following is a proposed adoption check, not a report of a completed pilot. You need an administrator who can verify billing and access, one person responsible for the tracker, and a reviewer who can define what counts as finished.
Create the brochure-proof task with an owner, date, source-file link and reviewer. Check that the responsible person can find it.
Reassign it, change the agreed date and mark it Waiting. Confirm that colleagues understand the change and can find the blocker and next action.
Move it to Ready for review, request a correction, then record reviewed completion. Keep the review decision explicit.
Check the intended client access using dummy material, including the linked file. Obtain a readable exit copy and note what it omits.
Record settings, timestamps, failures and upkeep effort. If the workflow meets the agreed needs, pilot one representative project before moving the remainder; retain the existing tracker until that check is complete.
If people disagree about the procedure or definition of done, resolve that separately; the guide to maintaining a small-team handbook addresses that knowledge problem.
The decision is then narrower: keep Sheets when the record is dependable; try ClickUp Free when dedicated tasks solve an identified gap; consider Core for a documented paid requirement; consider Asana Starter when its workflow fits and the annual commitment is affordable. The useful outcome is a record the team maintains—not another subscription everyone assumes someone else will update.
